A Journey of Hope

A Journey of Hope
by David Neuhaus SJ
A recent Vatican document on interreligious dialogue is titled “A Journey of Hope”. Published on September 16, 2026, its subtitle explains why it was published: “Sixty Years of Interreligious Dialogue and Fraternity in the Light of the Conciliar Declaration Nostra Aetate”.
The three-part document looks at the history of dialogue since Nostra Aetate, evaluates its fruits and challenges, and proposes future perspectives. The optimism of the 1960s that saw the world entering an epoch of peace has faded. Today, religious identities and institutions are frequently drawn into conflicts, and religious language is too often invoked to justify discrimination, violence, war, and even genocide. The document recommits the Church to the way of dialogue: “In a world that is both profoundly interconnected and also deeply fragmented, the message of Nostra Aetate remains highly relevant. Fraternity among believers of different religious traditions is not merely an ideal, but a moral, spiritual, and social imperative.”
Three Vatican dicasteries, Doctrine of the Faith, Promoting Christian Unity (which includes the commission for dialogue with the Jews), and Interreligious Dialogue, signed the document together. Such collaboration is unusual. However, the complexity of the challenges of dialogue today explains the need for a common approach.
A first challenge is the ongoing need to clarify, theologically, the tension between mission and dialogue. Christians believe that Jesus Christ is “the way, the truth and the life”, to whom they bear witness. However, at the same time, the Church urges Christians to engage honestly and respectfully in dialogue with believers from other faiths. According to the document, participation in interreligious dialogue “presupposes a sincere commitment, a deep understanding of the other, and recognition of the freedom of conscience as the foundation of every authentic relationship.” Dialogue is not “a matter of renouncing the truth but of proclaiming it in a manner befitting the Gospel: with esteem, listening, and charity.”
A second challenge concerns the Church’s relationship with the Jewish people. Dialogue with Jews was the starting point for the Church’s modern engagement with interreligious dialogue, and the document emphasises its distinctive character and significance for Christian identity. Yet it is not an endpoint; rather, it opens the Church to engagement with other religious communities. This has become more complex, as the document underlines, in an age of conflict, particularly in the Middle East. Channels of communication with the Jewish people “have been strained and continue to be tested by differing interpretations of the events that have unfolded.”
The ongoing Israeli destruction of Palestine has crippled many forums for Jewish-Catholic dialogue. However, Catholics remain dedicated to dialogue with both Jews and Muslims. They are challenged to find ways to build relations with both communities, without compromising the commitment to equality, justice and peace, affirming that all are created in the image of God. The document suggests that “a richer and more nuanced model of dialogue is therefore not only desirable for the future, but is already beginning to take shape in the Church and in its relations with other religious traditions.” Furthermore, the Church commits not only to fight against all forms of antisemitism but also to combat Islamophobia. Christian communities are called to open up to Muslims in “a spirit of welcome, as well as in greater knowledge and esteem”.
According to “A Journey of Hope”, dialogue does not require Christians to abandon their identity or convictions. Rather, it asks them to live those convictions in a way that makes room for encounter, listening, mutual respect, justice, and reconciliation.


